Self-Managed HOA vs. Professional HOA Management

What is a Self-Managed HOA?

A self-managed HOA is one where the board of directors and the homeowners handle management and maintenance of the community. Specific tasks include communicating with HOA membership, collecting dues, managing finances, coordinating capital projects, enforcing bylaws, maintaining common areas, and handling disputes. Self-managed HOAs are typically run by volunteers, so the board members do not receive any compensation for their work.

One of the reasons HOA’s choose self-management is cost savings. With a volunteer board in place, there is no need to pay a management company. Additionally, self-managed HOAs often have more control over their finances and can make decisions quickly.

Additionally, self-managed HOAs enjoy a sense of ownership and investment in the community. Since they are volunteers that reside in the community, they are typically very motivated to make decisions that benefit the community as a whole.

Self-Managed HOA Considerations

One of the biggest drawbacks of a self-managed HOA is that it can be very time-consuming. Board members may have other responsibilities such as work and family that can make it difficult to dedicate enough time to the HOA.

Another disadvantage of a self-managed HOA is that it can be challenging to find qualified volunteers to serve on the board. This can lead to a lack of diversity and expertise in the decision-making process and can limit the effectiveness of the HOA.

Finally, self-managed HOAs may not have access to the same resources as professional management companies, such as legal and accounting advice. This can make it challenging to handle complex issues and can lead to mistakes that affect the bottom line.

What is Professional HOA Management?

Professional HOA management involves hiring a third-party company to handle management and maintenance of the community. This includes tasks such as collecting dues, enforcing covenants and bylaws, maintaining common areas and facilities, and handling disputes. Professional management companies are typically paid a fee for their services.

Professional HOA management can take the burden off of the board members and homeowners. Since the management company handles all tasks related to managing and maintaining the community, the board members can focus on making decisions that benefit the community as a whole.

Professional management companies will also have access to the expertise and resources needed to manage the community effectively. They can provide legal and accounting advice, handle complex issues, and ensure that the community is in compliance with all regulations.

Finally, professional management companies can bring a level of professionalism and experience to the community. They can handle tasks efficiently and effectively, which can create cost savings.

Professional HOA Management Considerations

There is a cost associated with professional HOA management. Since management companies are paid a fee for their services, it can be more costly than self-management. Transitioning to professional HOA management is a process that requires strong communication and attention to detail. Since the management company is responsible for all tasks related to managing and maintaining the community, the board members should take an active role to ensure input in decision-making.

Regular communication is critical to ensure alignment of HOA goals and a shared focus.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an HOA Management Option

When deciding between self-managed and professional HOA management, there are several factors to consider including:

  • Years of experience
  • Size of the community
  • Complexity of tasks
  • Cost/Pricing model
  • Expertise of board members
  • Availability of volunteers
  • Desired level of control
  • Services offered
  • Community culture and values

It is important to carefully evaluate these factors and consider the unique needs of your community before making a decision.


In conclusion, the decision between self-managed and professional HOA management is an important one that should be carefully considered. By evaluating the factors outlined in this article, you can make an informed decision that will benefit your community in the long run.

Want More?

Share your your email address to receive the latest Ciminelli company news, real estate industry insights, and announcements.

Blog Want More?